I came across this UCLA Medical School Commencement Address by Dr Atul Gawande. Reading through it, I was struck by the solutions it offers for India’s current problems of rather frequent instances of violence on doctors in hospitals. The solution comes from the speaker’s philosophical thinking. I was also struck by the mission level commonality between the practice of medicine and practice of policing.

The first principle of the practice of medicine is that saving the life of any patient should be equally important to the treating doctor. Dr Gawande acknowledges that practitioners do not always live up to the principle. It is also the first principle of the practice of law enforcement- that there should be no distinction when acting upon complaints of persons from different social status. However, like in medical practice, but more so in policing, this principle is still only a goal to be achieved.

He mentions hospitals as places where you encounter the whole span of society-everyone, irrespective of position and means, needs medical care. Similar are the police stations- everyone needs good law enforcement work by police and the person’s position and means should be irrelevant for police when dealing with a victim or perpetrator of crime. Dr Gawande observes that US has a high incarceration rate ( currently 7 million people) and many of those incarcerated are blacks or the mentally ill and further, that 30% of the country’s adults carry a criminal arrest record! These figures are an eye opener about the unending circular link between poverty, social disadvantage and crime.

Impacting the nation’s economic growth and widely dispersing the benefits of better growth are not in the hands of the police but one of the significant fallouts of poverty and inequality is higher crime- which is fully a police responsibility. Poverty and inequality are two factors whose outcome is more crime in society. How then can the police cope with the hard problem of crime due to poverty and inequality?

Dr Gawande provides the solution for the medical fraternity- doctors need to be open to recognising the common core of humanity in each individual and develop curiosity for understanding what it feels like to be in the other’s shoes. In short, if doctors develop their capacity to empathise, it will help people dealing with doctors overcome their anger and fear through which they often act violently. I especially liked the way Dr Gawande expresses this ‘Once we lose the desire to understand-to be surprised, to listen and bear witness-we lose our humanity.’

What is in this solution which is beneficial for policing? Treating the especially vulnerable populations with understanding and respect means creating a more level playing field for access to justice. And what can cause this better understanding and respect? To my mind, it would be preventive policing through appropriate community policing schemes. It is therefore very important to nudge police activities in the direction of preventive policing through community policing. And a nudge which works here is the budgetary funding which government can provide for community policing schemes and supervised through performance audits of such schemes.

9 thoughts on “EQUALITY

  1. Dear Pradnya,

    Excellent articulation.

    I have always marveled at the similarity between medical and the profession of policing. However, one deals with individual pathology and the other deals with the social pathology. For individual ailments, the junior contact person is MBBS – trained for about five years; And for the ailments of troubled society the junior person is a constable, trained for about nine months!!

    One is trained at the cost of about fifty lakhs of rupees and the other just about one or two lakhs. The way society looks at the minions of law is rather dehumanizing.

    Your suggestion for state funded preventive action and community policing is welcome. I hope somebody in the government has time to read it.

    Affectionate regards,

    SS Puri


    Liked by 1 person

  2. Atul is relevant at all times and his books make inspiring reading. Glad you chose his commencement speech here for circulation among top cops. We await his next book. Thanks,
    S S Vaidyanathan
    Guj 1959

    Liked by 1 person

  3. I agree with S S Puri about the parallels between medical and police professions. Read Gawande’s “Check List” to see how he advocates systems and writes about what is common between the medical profession and Aviation.. S S Vaidyanathan

    Liked by 1 person

  4. There is commonality between police and medical profession, that is given, but to me, success of police is dependent on looking at each individual, as a unique representative of God. If we start resolving individual problems, social problems will disappear.
    What is often a social problem, is insecurity of individual writ large.

    Liked by 1 person

  5. He is great thinker despite being a surgeon, and has tried to pick up from different professions like building industry and aviation
    you are the same:)

    Liked by 1 person

  6. Thank you, Pradnya.
    Considering the resource constraints under which most policing is done, the analogy with the medical profession could be extended to triage.
    Or would that be burking? 😉
    Wishing greater power to your pen,


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s