It’s Time to Turn Around Policing in India

20140721-005109-3069121.jpgRecently there was news about rape by police station officers in Mumbai. There was also news about the inaction by police during the live suicide of a farmer perched on a tree in Delhi.

To me, these news items are red flags for the relevance of Police as a service, as it exists now, in India. Clearly, the thoughtful police leaders are also seeing serious concerns on the quality of service delivered by the rank and file of their organizations especially vis a vis the public expectation. In Mumbai, the Police Commissioner talked of identifying the black sheep in the department and transferring  them to jobs with least public dealings.

Policing is meant to make society feel safe, and at the very least, policemen are expected not to uproot this trust by committing heinous crimes themselves. I’m sure the criminals in uniform will be dealt with very severely in the department. But how does one bring in a working culture in police stations where the policemen feel a responsibility towards making their jurisdictions safer?

This ‘feeling safe’ is a very fey goal. It would mean, at the very least, that the police stations keep an authentic record of all crimes in society and investigate those that have an impact on public safety (and not get bogged down in investigating petty crimes which can be settled or arbitrated through insurance). The actions by police and courts on the reported crimes should then result in an overall feeling of safety due to a genuinely low-crime scenario.  ‘Feeling safe’ also happens when police do effective intelligence based preventive work on the disruptive but rare ‘enemy’ activities like terrorism.

So, I ask the question, in our country, on the backdrop of rampant non registration of crimes in police stations and the poor disposal of criminal cases in courts, is it a fair expectation that police in India can make people ‘feel safe’? Or, on a little hopeful note, at least as far as the police is concerned, what can make policemen in police stations more accountable to the people they are supposed to keep safe?

If I consider the police in Mumbai, it is a large organisation of approx 55000 people with the bulk of its personnel in the constabulary. The organisational pyramid is very wide bottomed. How does one transform this organisation to being perceptibly responsive to public complaints, and thereby significantly improve the status of ‘feeling safe’? And also achieve this in such a way that it is not dependent on who the DCP or CP is, at any point of time. To my mind, the police leadership at the top management level needs to focus on making the police stations as public accountable units.

One way to attempt a solution to this vexing problem is to obtain an independent measure of crime levels per police station by conducting Crime Victimization Surveys. This can show up the level of ‘burking’ of crime in police stations i.e non recording of FIRs in reported crimes. A spotlight on this difference can be a self correcting measure for the police stations. And it can be expected that once this is corrected, the right number and value of resources will be allocated to police by governments. Currently, with the ridiculous statistics of falling crime numbers year on year, police is only in the maintenance mode as far as funds are concerned. It is a hopeless situation for enhancing funds for policing.

Such Surveys will also focus the spotlight on the increasing or decreasing public perception of ‘feeling safe’, which again can be expected to work as a self correcting measure for the police station staff to make the necessary changes in their response and behaviour towards the people who seek police help.

I’ve written about these Surveys earlier on this blog. But they are yet an untested idea in India. I think it’s time for some serious experimentation in changing the way we do policing in India. Something may work.

Advertisements

7 thoughts on “It’s Time to Turn Around Policing in India

  1. First of all the police have to get rid of their obsession with crime-fighting, as this is primarily responsible for their deviant behaviour – illegal detention, third degree, brutality, fabrication of evidence – which gives them the excuse to indulge in such behaviour even when no crime fighting is involved.

    Like

  2. Police have to learn to partner with the public and jointly prevent as envisaged in Policing started by Robert Peel. For this the cutting edge would have to be empowered and motivated to adopt a non enforcement attitude. Leaders should aim at developing confidence and self respect in constabulary. Communication skills rather than macho military type drill has to get priority in training. The percentage of directly recruited Sub Inspectors with good promotional prospects should drastically increase and the foot soldier number cut down. Farming out many tasks like attending calls, running Daily Diary and even registering cases and dispatch of patrols and duties should be given to trained Civilans. Station Diary should be computer programme generated and linked with Dial 100.

    Like

  3. Dear Saravade, I fully agree with your idea that crime victim survey is one of the more effective means of finding out the true incidence of crime instead of relying on cooked-up police statistics. Many western countries now depend upon crime victim survey as a more reliable means of finding out the true incidence of crime. I had earlier written to BPR&D for this kind of survey and also suggested the same to National Security Advisor. So far I have drawn a blank but cudgels have to be taken up by young officers like you. Such surveys may expose the absurdity and unreality of the police statistics but will be an important step towards fashioning realistic strategies for containing crime. From our Institute of Social Sciences we had done a crime victims survey with a minuscule sample but the results were revealing.
    Sankar Sen, IPS (Retd.)

    Like

  4. Dear Sirs,
    The difficult problem is how to shake the status quoism in the police and bureaucratic and political establishment, as far as the service delivery parameters and organisational culture go. Once the need for change becomes a motivating factor(the crime victimization surveys have that potential, at least theoretically), the solutions suggested by Shri Koshy Sir and Shri Pandey Sir, can be brought about. I wish it is tried out.
    Rgds
    Pradnya

    Like

  5. Pradnya,
    Has any police entity – in India or abroad – carried out this kind of survey?
    It is a worthwhile suggestion – to stem the rot, we must know the amount of rot.
    Rgrds

    Like

    1. Dear Sir
      This survey is not carried out yet by any police organization in India. But it has been around for many decades in other countries like US, Hongkong, Australia etc. to my mind, it’s an idea that could turn policing around through measuring improvements in police accountability and street crime. I’ve written about it earlier too and you may like to read https://pradnyanblog.wordpress.com/2013/09/10/crime-victimization-surveys-for-police-reforms/.
      Rgds

      Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s